The Simply Scary Podcast

In this chilling seasonal installment of Chilling Tales for Dark Nights, comfort becomes camouflage—and the familiar transforms into something watchful, patient, and deeply wrong. Small disturbances go unnoticed. Patterns are dismissed. Reassurance replaces vigilance. Until it doesn’t. What begins as a harmless irregularity grows steadily more insistent, revealing an intelligence that understands timing, proximity, and consequence. Each moment brings it closer. Each choice narrows the margin for escape. Featuring a haunting performance by Beth Gadow and a special guest appearance from Evil Idol 2025 standout Lunara Rebelle, “Merry Malice” is a quiet, methodical descent into holiday horror—where tradition is tested, coincidence erodes, and something unseen waits for permission to finish what it has started. “Something Keeps Removing the Star From My Christmas Tree” by Craig Groshek – Looking to reclaim a sense of comfort during a difficult holiday season, Marcy decorates her home with care—only to notice th